Indian cricket selections have always been questioned, star of India’s 1983 World Cup triumph Mohinder Amarnath once famously called Indian selectors a bunch of jokers. Fair enough, after every selection decision, fans disagree, former cricketers express disappointment, experts dissect playing combinations, and social media erupts whenever a favourite player misses out.
That is part and parcel for cricket selectors in a country where the sport is practically a religion. But the decision to leave Mohammed Siraj out of India’s playing XI for the Wellington Test has taken an unfortunate turn, with sections of social media and politicians attempting to turn a cricketing decision into a communal controversy.
#WATCH | Delhi: On Cricketer Mohammed Siraj, Congress MP Imran Masood says, “It is being said that despite his good performance, he was not given a place in the team. His name is ‘Siraj ‘, and that is why he was not given a place. If you are not selecting him despite his good performance, the discrimination is clear.”— ANI (@ANI) November 20, 2026
Yes, the Indian team management deserves to be questioned. Siraj is an experienced international fast bowler who has repeatedly delivered for India, particularly in overseas conditions. Leaving him out was always going to invite scrutiny. There is a legitimate cricketing debate to be had here. Though his recent record is five wickets in his last seven bowling innings so not like he was on fire.
But here is an inconvenient detail for those trying to communalise the selection, star Indian allrounder Ravindra Jadeja was also left out of the playing XI. Jadeja is a Hindu, is the 5th highest wicket-taker for India, has been the 2nd best Indian batsman overseas during the last decade, and is among the best fielders in the world. Does his exclusion suddenly make this a case of discrimination against Hindus? Of course not. Or at least, that is the logic one would expect everyone to apply consistently.
The management has to explain its selection decisions, irrespective of which player is affected. If Siraj’s exclusion deserves scrutiny, so does Jadeja’s. Both are accomplished international cricketers, and both have contributed significantly to Indian cricket. Their omission can be debated on merit, form, conditions and team combinations.
But suggesting that Siraj was dropped because of his religion requires evidence, not social media speculation.
The team management’s selection philosophy can certainly be questioned. Was batting depth more important than Siraj’s pace and experience? Was leaving out Jadeja the right tactical decision? Could India have assembled a better combination? These are perfectly legitimate questions for cricket experts, former players and fans to debate.
What is not legitimate is turning every selection decision involving a Muslim cricketer into evidence of communal discrimination while conveniently ignoring that a Hindu cricketer was also dropped.
Siraj is an Indian cricketer. So is Jadeja. Neither deserves to have their sporting career reduced to their religious identity.
So, yes, question the management. Ask why Siraj was left out. Demand consistency and transparency in selection. But do not manufacture a communal controversy without evidence.
Cricket deserves better than this. Siraj deserves an honest assessment of his performances, Jadeja deserves the same, and Indian cricket deserves a conversation where wickets, averages and team combinations matter more than religious identities.
