Sadly, Uttar Pradesh Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath’s mother passed away recently, and our condolences, losing a parent hits hard. People even tried to use this sad occasion for their political propaganda and tried to use this sad occasion to try and create a Modi vs Yogi narrative.
Prime Minister Narendra Modi personally called Uttar Pradesh Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath following the passing of his mother, expressing his condolences during a deeply personal moment of grief. Yet, instead of recognising the human gesture, some sections of social media have chosen to manufacture a controversy because the Prime Minister did not put out a public tweet. Apparently, in today’s politics, even grief must come with a social media notification. Because without social media posts, nothing really matters.
Let us get one thing straight. When someone loses their mother, what matters more? A personal telephone call from the Prime Minister of the country or a carefully worded Twitter (Yes Elon, its is still Twitter, nobody calls it X) post for public consumption? Is expressing sympathy about comforting the grieving person or satisfying social media commentators looking for another opportunity to manufacture political divisions?
There is something particularly distasteful about turning someone’s personal tragedy into a political talking point. Yogi Adityanath has lost his mother. This is a moment for compassion, dignity and prayers, not an opportunity to scrutinise the Prime Minister’s social media activity and manufacture imaginary differences between two leaders.
A personal conversation is ALWAYS far more meaningful than a public statement. A phone call allows someone to speak privately, offer comfort and convey emotions without an audience. A tweet, however well-intentioned, is a public message. You share someone’s grief in private, you don’t make a public spectacle out of it. PM Modi obviously understands that, social media warriors don’t.
Would those questioning Modi’s response genuinely prefer that he had skipped the personal call and instead posted a photograph with a standard condolence message? Would that somehow have made his sympathy more genuine?
Unfortunately, this is what political discourse has increasingly become, an endless hunt for perceived slights, imagined insults and manufactured controversies. Even a personal tragedy is not spared from the machinery of political point-scoring.
There is a time to question governments, challenge leaders and hold politicians accountable. But there must also be a time to behave like human beings.
A mother’s passing is a deeply personal loss. Let the family grieve in peace. And perhaps those busy counting tweets should remember that compassion is not measured by social media engagement. Sometimes, the most meaningful condolences are the ones that never make it to the timeline.
